Is the As Seen on TV Ice Scraper Any Good? What to Know Before You Buy
Wondering if the as seen on TV ice scraper actually clears ice well? Here's what to expect, what it does poorly, and how to choose a scraper that works.
Updated November 2026
The as seen on TV ice scraper is a mixed bag. Most of these tools work fine on light frost and fresh snow, but they tend to struggle with thick, glazed ice and can leave marks on glass if used carelessly. Treat them as a convenient backup, not a full replacement for a sturdy, purpose-built scraper and a bit of warm-up time.
Why these scrapers struggle with real ice
Most infomercial scrapers are built around a thin plastic blade and a lightweight handle. That design works well on powdery frost, but thick ice needs leverage and a rigid edge. When the blade flexes under pressure, it skips across the surface instead of breaking the bond between ice and glass, and you end up pushing harder to get less done.
Shopping for one? See our guide: 6 Best Window Scrapers for Ice Picks for Cars and Trucks (2026).
The factors that decide whether it works
- Blade stiffness. A blade that bends when you press on it will chatter and wear quickly. Look for a firm edge that holds its shape.
- Blade material. Thin, sharp-edged plastic is more likely to gouge glass than a wider, rounded polymer blade.
- Handle length. A short handle forces you to lean over the hood or roof, which often means more force on a smaller area.
- Ice thickness. Frost and a thin skin of sleet are manageable. Anything thicker than about a sixteenth of an inch usually needs de-icer or warm water first.
What to do for better results
Whatever scraper you own, a few habits cut the damage and the effort in half.
- Start the engine and run the defroster on high for 5 to 10 minutes so the ice begins to loosen.
- Clear snow first with a soft brush or a snow broom so the scraper meets only ice.
- Hold the blade at a low angle, around 30 degrees, and use short, firm strokes rather than sweeping arcs.
- Never pour boiling or very hot water on cold glass. Lukewarm water or a windshield-safe de-icer is safer.
- Stop if the blade starts to skip or squeal. That sound usually means grit is trapped under the edge.
What we’d use
If you want a scraper that handles stubborn ice better than most infomercial models, look for a longer handle with a rigid, wide blade. A heavy-duty ice scraper with a brush head covers both snow and glazed ice. For a gentler option on delicate glass, a View on Amazon pairs a soft blade with a squeegee for quick cleanup after the ice is gone.
For related buying advice, see Which Car Convenient Ice Scraper Works Best? Features That Matter and Brass Ice Scraper vs Plastic (2026): Which Is Better for Your Car?.
FAQ
Does the as seen on TV ice scraper damage windshields?
It can, especially if the blade is thin or has grit on it. Clearing snow first and keeping the blade at a low angle reduces the risk. If you see fine scratches, check Scratches on Windscreen from Ice Scraper: How to Prevent and Fix Them.
Can it remove thick ice?
Usually not on its own. Thick ice is better handled with a de-icer or by running the defroster first, then scraping what loosens.
Is it worth buying over a regular scraper?
For occasional light frost, it can be fine. If you deal with heavy ice regularly, a stiffer, longer-handled scraper will serve you better. Consult the manufacturer’s care guidance for your windshield type if you’re unsure.
Related reading
- Why Does My Ice Scraper Scratch Paint? Causes and Fixes
- What Is a Good Alternative for Ice Scraper? 5 Options That Work
- Top 5 Ice Scrapers with Brush Options for Cars and Trucks (2026)
- How to Get Ice Off Windshield Without Scraper: 5 Fast Methods That Work
- Microspikes vs Ice Cleats (2026): Which Is Better for Winter Walking?
Ready to choose one?
